Discord X
Region:
Keyshops:
in progress...
Pony Island

Games like Pony Island

Back to Game

Looking for the best games like Pony Island? We put together 24 similar titles that match in genre, gameplay, and atmosphere. Compare prices across official stores and key sellers and pick up your next favorite game at the lowest price.

Similar Games (24)

Inscryption
-73%
Strategy Indie Adventure
Inscryption
Windows Mac Linux Steam Deck Playable 19 Oct. 2021 Steam Epic Games Launcher
Eneba Eneba +21
from C$8.28
Compare Prices
Inscryption Game
Inscryption
Release: 19 Oct. 2021
Strategy
Indie
Adventure
Windows
Mac
Linux
Steam Deck Playable
DRM:
Steam
Epic Games Launcher
Windows
Mac
Linux
Steam Deck Playable
-73%
From:
C$8.28
Compare Prices
Eneba
Eneba
and 21 stores
Dread X Collection 2
Historical Low
-70%
Action Indie Adventure
Dread X Collection 2
Windows Steam Deck Playable 21 Aug. 2020 Steam
Steam Steam
from C$3.44
Compare Prices
Dread X Collection 2 Game
Dread X Collection 2
Release: 21 Aug. 2020
Action
Indie
Adventure
Windows
Steam Deck Playable
DRM:
Steam
Windows
Steam Deck Playable
Historical Low
HL
-70%
From:
C$3.44
Compare Prices
Steam
Steam
The Hex
-90%
Indie
The Hex
Windows Mac Linux Steam Deck Playable 16 Oct. 2018 Steam
Kinguin Kinguin +6
from C$1.28
Compare Prices
The Hex Game
The Hex
Release: 16 Oct. 2018
Indie
Windows
Mac
Linux
Steam Deck Playable
DRM:
Steam
Windows
Mac
Linux
Steam Deck Playable
-90%
From:
C$1.28
Compare Prices
Kinguin
Kinguin
and 6 stores
Megabonk
-25%
Action Indie Casual
Megabonk
Windows Linux Steam Deck Unsupported 18 Sep. 2025 Steam
Steam Steam +3
from C$9.74
Compare Prices
Megabonk Game
Megabonk
Release: 18 Sep. 2025
Action
Indie
Casual
Windows
Linux
Steam Deck Unsupported
DRM:
Steam
Windows
Linux
Steam Deck Unsupported
-25%
From:
C$9.74
Compare Prices
Steam
Steam
and 3 stores
Absolum
Historical Low
-25%
Action Indie RPG
Absolum
Windows Steam Deck Playable 09 Oct. 2025 Steam
Steam Steam +9
from C$24.37
Compare Prices
Absolum Game
Absolum
Release: 09 Oct. 2025
Action
Indie
RPG
Windows
Steam Deck Playable
DRM:
Steam
Windows
Steam Deck Playable
Historical Low
HL
-25%
From:
C$24.37
Compare Prices
Steam
Steam
and 9 stores
CloverPit
Historical Low
-20%
Strategy Indie Simulation
CloverPit
Windows Steam Deck Unsupported 26 Sep. 2025 Steam
Steam Steam +3
from C$10.39
Compare Prices
CloverPit Game
CloverPit
Release: 26 Sep. 2025
Strategy
Indie
Simulation
Windows
Steam Deck Unsupported
DRM:
Steam
Windows
Steam Deck Unsupported
Historical Low
HL
-20%
From:
C$10.39
Compare Prices
Steam
Steam
and 3 stores
Quarantine Zone: The Last Check
Historical Low
-52%
Strategy Indie Simulation
Quarantine Zone: The Last Check
Windows Steam Deck Playable 12 Jan. 2026 Steam
Eneba Eneba +14
from C$14.90
Compare Prices
Quarantine Zone: The Last Check Game
Quarantine Zone: The Last Check
Release: 12 Jan. 2026
Strategy
Indie
Simulation
Windows
Steam Deck Playable
DRM:
Steam
Windows
Steam Deck Playable
Historical Low
HL
-52%
From:
C$14.90
Compare Prices
Eneba
Eneba
and 14 stores
Half Sword
Historical Low
-26%
Action Indie Simulation
Half Sword
Windows Steam Deck Playable 04 Apr. 2025 Steam Epic Games Launcher
Kinguin Kinguin +2
from C$27.88
Compare Prices
Half Sword Game
Half Sword
Release: 04 Apr. 2025
Action
Indie
Simulation
Windows
Steam Deck Playable
DRM:
Steam
Epic Games Launcher
Windows
Steam Deck Playable
Historical Low
HL
-26%
From:
C$27.88
Compare Prices
Kinguin
Kinguin
and 2 stores
Dispatch
-10%
Action Strategy Indie
Dispatch
Windows Steam Deck Unsupported 22 Oct. 2025 Steam
Steam Steam +2
from C$35.09
Compare Prices
Dispatch Game
Dispatch
Release: 22 Oct. 2025
Action
Strategy
Indie
Windows
Steam Deck Unsupported
DRM:
Steam
Windows
Steam Deck Unsupported
-10%
From:
C$35.09
Compare Prices
Steam
Steam
and 2 stores
Lethal Company
Historical Low
-25%
Action Indie Adventure
Lethal Company
Windows Steam Deck Playable 23 Oct. 2023 Steam
Steam Steam +3
from C$9.74
Compare Prices
Lethal Company Game
Lethal Company
Release: 23 Oct. 2023
Action
Indie
Adventure
Windows
Steam Deck Playable
DRM:
Steam
Windows
Steam Deck Playable
Historical Low
HL
-25%
From:
C$9.74
Compare Prices
Steam
Steam
and 3 stores
Hollow Knight: Silksong
Historical Low
-72%
Action Indie Adventure
Hollow Knight: Silksong
Windows Linux Steam Deck Unsupported 04 Sep. 2025 Steam
Gameseal Gameseal +32
from C$7.16
Compare Prices
Hollow Knight: Silksong Game
Hollow Knight: Silksong
Release: 04 Sep. 2025
Action
Indie
Adventure
Windows
Linux
Steam Deck Unsupported
DRM:
Steam
Windows
Linux
Steam Deck Unsupported
Historical Low
HL
-72%
From:
C$7.16
Compare Prices
Gameseal
Gameseal
and 32 stores
Satisfactory
-41%
Strategy Indie Simulation
Satisfactory
Windows Steam Deck Unsupported 10 Sep. 2024 Steam Epic Games Launcher
Eneba Eneba +14
from C$36.25
Compare Prices
Satisfactory Game
Satisfactory
Release: 10 Sep. 2024
Strategy
Indie
Simulation
Windows
Steam Deck Unsupported
DRM:
Steam
Epic Games Launcher
Windows
Steam Deck Unsupported
-41%
From:
C$36.25
Compare Prices
Eneba
Eneba
and 14 stores
Wallpaper Engine
-34%
Indie Casual Animation & Modeling
Wallpaper Engine
Windows Steam Deck Verified 16 Nov. 2018 Steam
Eneba Eneba +12
from C$5.19
Compare Prices
Wallpaper Engine Game
Wallpaper Engine
Release: 16 Nov. 2018
Indie
Casual
Animation & Modeling
Windows
Steam Deck Verified
DRM:
Steam
Windows
Steam Deck Verified
-34%
From:
C$5.19
Compare Prices
Eneba
Eneba
and 12 stores
Phasmophobia
-30%
Action Indie Early Access
Phasmophobia
Windows Steam Deck Verified 18 Sep. 2020 Steam
Steam Steam +9
from C$18.19
Compare Prices
Phasmophobia Game
Phasmophobia
Release: 18 Sep. 2020
Action
Indie
Early Access
Windows
Steam Deck Verified
DRM:
Steam
Windows
Steam Deck Verified
-30%
From:
C$18.19
Compare Prices
Steam
Steam
and 9 stores
StarRupture
Historical Low
-43%
Action Indie Simulation
StarRupture
Windows Steam Deck Playable 06 Jan. 2026 Steam
Gameseal Gameseal +22
from C$14.65
Compare Prices
StarRupture Game
StarRupture
Release: 06 Jan. 2026
Action
Indie
Simulation
Windows
Steam Deck Playable
DRM:
Steam
Windows
Steam Deck Playable
Historical Low
HL
-43%
From:
C$14.65
Compare Prices
Gameseal
Gameseal
and 22 stores
7 Days to Die
-70%
Action Strategy Indie
7 Days to Die
Windows Mac Linux Steam Deck Unsupported 25 Jul. 2024 Steam
Eneba Eneba +28
from C$20.24
Compare Prices
7 Days to Die Game
7 Days to Die
Release: 25 Jul. 2024
Action
Strategy
Indie
Windows
Mac
Linux
Steam Deck Unsupported
DRM:
Steam
Windows
Mac
Linux
Steam Deck Unsupported
-70%
From:
C$20.24
Compare Prices
Eneba
Eneba
and 28 stores
Valheim
-50%
Action Indie RPG
Valheim
Windows Mac Linux Steam Deck Unsupported 02 Feb. 2021 Steam
Steam Steam +20
from C$13.49
Compare Prices
Valheim Game
Valheim
Release: 02 Feb. 2021
Action
Indie
RPG
Windows
Mac
Linux
Steam Deck Unsupported
DRM:
Steam
Windows
Mac
Linux
Steam Deck Unsupported
-50%
From:
C$13.49
Compare Prices
Steam
Steam
and 20 stores
Vampire Survivors
-68%
Action Indie RPG
Vampire Survivors
Windows Mac Steam Deck Unsupported 20 Oct. 2022 Steam Epic Games Launcher
Eneba Eneba +7
from C$2.52
Compare Prices
Vampire Survivors Game
Vampire Survivors
Release: 20 Oct. 2022
Action
Indie
RPG
Windows
Mac
Steam Deck Unsupported
DRM:
Steam
Epic Games Launcher
Windows
Mac
Steam Deck Unsupported
-68%
From:
C$2.52
Compare Prices
Eneba
Eneba
and 7 stores
Stardew Valley
-40%
Indie RPG Simulation
Stardew Valley
Windows Mac Linux Steam Deck Unsupported 26 Feb. 2016 Steam GOG Microsoft Store
Steam Steam +31
from C$10.19
Compare Prices
Stardew Valley Game
Stardew Valley
Release: 26 Feb. 2016
Indie
RPG
Simulation
Windows
Mac
Linux
Steam Deck Unsupported
DRM:
Steam
GOG
Microsoft Store
Windows
Mac
Linux
Steam Deck Unsupported
-40%
From:
C$10.19
Compare Prices
Steam
Steam
and 31 stores
Raft
Historical Low
-33%
Indie Simulation Adventure
Raft
Windows Steam Deck Playable 20 Jun. 2022 Steam
Steam Steam
from C$14.73
Compare Prices
Raft Game
Raft
Release: 20 Jun. 2022
Indie
Simulation
Adventure
Windows
Steam Deck Playable
DRM:
Steam
Windows
Steam Deck Playable
Historical Low
HL
-33%
From:
C$14.73
Compare Prices
Steam
Steam
Sons Of The Forest
-69%
Action Indie Simulation
Sons Of The Forest
Windows Steam Deck Verified 22 Feb. 2024 Steam
Steam Steam +3
from C$12.08
Compare Prices
Sons Of The Forest Game
Sons Of The Forest
Release: 22 Feb. 2024
Action
Indie
Simulation
Windows
Steam Deck Verified
DRM:
Steam
Windows
Steam Deck Verified
-69%
From:
C$12.08
Compare Prices
Steam
Steam
and 3 stores
The Forest
Historical Low
-77%
Action Indie Simulation
The Forest
Windows Steam Deck Playable 30 Apr. 2018 Steam
Steam Steam +11
from C$5.24
Compare Prices
The Forest Game
The Forest
Release: 30 Apr. 2018
Action
Indie
Simulation
Windows
Steam Deck Playable
DRM:
Steam
Windows
Steam Deck Playable
Historical Low
HL
-77%
From:
C$5.24
Compare Prices
Steam
Steam
and 11 stores
Terraria
-84%
Action Indie RPG
Terraria
Windows Mac Linux Steam Deck Unsupported 16 May 2011 Steam GOG
Eneba Eneba +39
from C$2.35
Compare Prices
Terraria Game
Terraria
Release: 16 May 2011
Action
Indie
RPG
Windows
Mac
Linux
Steam Deck Unsupported
DRM:
Steam
GOG
Windows
Mac
Linux
Steam Deck Unsupported
-84%
From:
C$2.35
Compare Prices
Eneba
Eneba
and 39 stores
Rust
-40%
Action Indie RPG
Rust
Windows Mac Steam Deck Verified 08 Feb. 2018 Steam
Steam Steam +10
from C$31.19
Compare Prices
Rust Game
Rust
Release: 08 Feb. 2018
Action
Indie
RPG
Windows
Mac
Steam Deck Verified
DRM:
Steam
Windows
Mac
Steam Deck Verified
-40%
From:
C$31.19
Compare Prices
Steam
Steam
and 10 stores
Join our Discord
Get instant help from our community and stay updated on the latest deals
Join Now
Set Price Alerts
Get notified by email when game prices drop to your target
My Alerts
Create Free Account
Unlock wishlists, price alerts, and Steam sync
Sign Up Free

What should I play if I liked Pony Island?

Finished Pony Island and looking for something similar? You're in the right place. We've handpicked games that share the same genre, mechanics, and feel. Whether you want more of the same gameplay loop or something that takes the formula in a new direction, this list has you covered.

Exploring alternatives to Pony Island is also a great way to discover franchises you might have missed. Many of these titles offer a fresh take on what made Pony Island enjoyable, so give them a try and you might find your next obsession.

Where to find the best prices on games like Pony Island?

xd.deals compares prices from dozens of official stores and keyshops so you can find the cheapest deal on every alternative to Pony Island. Each game card shows two prices: the lowest offer from official stores and the best price from key sellers. Official stores provide direct publisher support, while keyshops may offer deeper discounts with some trade-offs. Pick whichever option fits your budget and preference.

Can't find the right alternative to Pony Island?

If none of the games on this list caught your eye, head over to our games page and use the filter system to search by genre, Steam tags, or player ratings. You can also browse our news section for editorial recommendations and themed lists that might lead you to exactly what you're looking for.