Home › News › GTA 6 Review Bombed on Metacritic Despite 99 Metascore

GTA 6 Review Bombed on Metacritic Despite 99 Metascore

A 99 from critics, the biggest entertainment launch ever... and a user score on Metacritic that's sunk below 5. GTA 6 is getting review bombed, and honestly, I'm not even surprised.

GTA 6 launched on PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series on November 19. The PS5 version sits at 99 on Metacritic from around 150 reviews. The only other game to ever hit that number is the original The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time from 1998, so the two now share the top spot in the site's history.

Zeros, zeros everywhere

Flip over to the user tab and it's a different story. On Friday evening the average was 4.9 from 6,780 ratings. By early Saturday it had crawled back to 5.4, which Metacritic files under "Mixed or Average". Most of the negative reviews are a flat 0 with a line like "Overrated game" attached. One user went for "More like Slop Theft Auto". Creative, I'll give them that.

The complaints fall into three buckets. Some players say critics went soft and ignored the flaws. Others point at performance, since the game runs at 30fps on consoles and doesn't always hold it. The third one is the weird one. A chunk of the crowd is upset that Jason is kind and protective toward Lucia (apparently that counts as "woke" in certain corners of the internet).

The numbers don't care

None of this is denting sales. Take-Two says 32.5 million copies were sold before launch. Day one brought in $3.79 billion in retail sales, which makes it the biggest launch in entertainment history, movies and music included.

Circana's Mat Piscatella added another wild stat. In the US, 61% of PS5 owners played GTA 6 on launch day, for an average of eight hours. That's a lot of sick days.

Also, keep in mind how Metacritic works. Anyone can leave a score there, whether they've played the game or not. On the PlayStation Store, where owners do the rating, GTA 6 sits above 4.8 out of 5 from roughly 170,000 ratings. That feels like a better read on how players actually feel.

Grand Theft Auto VI PSN Download Key (Playstation) UNITED STATES (NA)
3d ago
$118.53$78.90
-33%
Grand Theft Auto VI (PS5) - PSN Key - UNITED STATES
9h ago
$99.99$80.33
-19%
Grand Theft Auto VI (PS5)
9h ago
$99.99$81.05
-18%
Grand Theft Auto VI (Xbox Series X/S) - Xbox Live Key - GLOBAL
9h ago
$79.99$67.29
-15%
Grand Theft Auto VI PRE-ORDER (Xbox Series X|S) Xbox Live Key - GLOBAL
1d ago
$79.99$69.60
-12%
Grand Theft Auto VI XBOX Series X|S
14h ago
$79.99$69.99
-12%

My take

A pile of zeros in launch week says more about the mood online than about the game itself. The frame drops are a fair complaint, though, and I'd rather people keep talking about that one. The rest? It'll be forgotten in a few weeks.

You can find GTA 6 for PS5 and GTA 6 for Xbox Series on our site. Already rolled the credits and want more? Check out our list of games like GTA 6.

So what do you think? Does GTA 6 deserve that 99, or did the critics get carried away? Let me know in the comments!