Home › News › Binding of Isaac Pulls AI Music From Its GTA 6 Daily Run

Binding of Isaac Pulls AI Music From Its GTA 6 Daily Run

A GTA 6 themed run on GTA 6 launch day? Cute idea. Then somebody dug into the music files, found an AI generator's fingerprints all over them, and Steam reviews for The Binding of Isaac: Repentance+ went off a cliff.

Repentance+ finally hit Switch 2, PS5 and Xbox Series X/S on November 19, the exact same day GTA 6 came out. That date was publisher Nicalis's idea, and series creator Edmund McMillen thought it was funny enough to roll with. To lean into the bit, the update shipped a special crime-flavored Daily Run where you tear through the basement like it's Vice City.

"Made with Suno"

The joke lasted about a day. Reddit user ShweetsStuff pulled apart the 14 music tracks from that run and found "made with Suno" sitting in the metadata of several of them. Suno, if you haven't run into it, is one of the big AI music generators. One file was even stamped October 30, less than three weeks before launch.

The bigger issue? Nobody said a word. Steam requires developers to disclose AI-generated content on the store page, and the Repentance+ page had nothing of the sort. So players did what players do. Only around 8-10% of recent Steam reviews are positive right now, which puts it at "Overwhelmingly Negative".

McMillen "had no idea"

On Saturday McMillen posted on X that he "woke up to a s**t show." He said he had no clue the Daily Run featured generated music and that he was looking into how it happened and getting it removed. A few hours later Nicalis pushed a patch whose notes simply list the "removal of generated music files."

The fix is live on PC already. Console versions have been submitted to Microsoft, Nintendo and Sony, though there's no date yet. And no, Nicalis hasn't explained how the tracks got into the build in the first place.

Release: 4 Nov 2014
Metacritic:
86
8.2
The Binding of Isaac: Rebirth Steam Gift
+3
3h ago
$14.99$7.91
-47%
The Binding of Isaac: Rebirth Steam Key: Brazil (REGION SPECIFIC)
+3
3d ago
$14.48$8.40
-41%
The Binding of Isaac: Rebirth (PC) - Steam Gift - GLOBAL
+3
9h ago
$14.99$8.71
-41%

My take

I'm not going to pile on McMillen here. He's mostly busy with Mewgenics these days, and Isaac's ports and updates run through Nicalis. Pulling the music this fast was the right call. Still, a series that's been hand-crafted since 2011 deserves more than a one-line patch note (fans want to know who slipped those tracks in).

New to Isaac? Start with The Binding of Isaac: Rebirth, since every expansion builds on top of it, Repentance included.

So what do you think? Is yanking the tracks enough, or does Nicalis owe everyone a proper explanation? Let me know in the comments.